INTERNAL TALK 5 - INTRODUCTION TO PHILOSOPHY OF RELIGION - HUỲNH DUY THANH - Sep 6th, 2021
07/
09/
2021
- Philosophy of religion: Introduction and basic questions
- What is God?
- Traditional arguments for the existence of God
- The Five Ways of St. Thomas Aquinas
- Q&A.
In the first part, the speaker explained the difference between philosophy of religion and religious studies (cultural anthropology). Philosophy of religion is a part of Special Metaphysics, in which four basic questions are asked: (1) What is God?, (2) Does God exist?, (3) How do we account for evil in the universe?, and (4) What is the nature of faith?
To answer the first question, the speaker presented some possible definitions of God. The first definition is Theism which conceives God must has four properties, namely, (a) Omnipotent (toàn năng), (b) Omniscient (toàn tri), (c) Omnibenevolent (toàn thiện), and (d) Personal (ngôi vị) or a 'social being' who cares and oversees our universe. The second definition is Deism which agrees with Theism in the first two properties but asks for another property, namely, being perfect creator. As a consequence, the universe is perfectly created and therefore, no interference by God is necessary. The third definition is Pantheism which is essentially an immanent concept and identifies the universe with God. Lastly, Panentheism is the middle way between the third definition and the first two, All is in God.
In the third part, the speaker explained five kinds of traditional arguments for the existence of God. They are (1) ontological, (2) cosmological, (3) teleological, (4) religious experience, and (5) moral (by Kant). To illustrate the arguments, the speaker presented and explained The Five Ways by St. Thomas Aquinas in Summa Theologica (Tổng luận thần học) and many other arguments.
In the Q&A section, a few questions were inquired: Are religions good or bad? Is Covid-19 pandemic a retribution? Does God arrange and determine all events in the universe? With so many sound arguments on the existence of God, why do people still not believe in God? The most interesting question was put from pragmatic point of view in James-style: What are practical consequences if God exists or does not exist? This question was really too great for us to even start to tackle in a short discussion.